Serving Bucks & Montgomery Counties, Southeastern Pennsylvania and nearby New JerseyServing Southeastern PA & nearby NJMon–Fri 8am–8pm · Sat 8am–2pm · Customer Login

Stucco Remediation vs. New Siding: How to Choose

Stucco Remediation vs. New Siding: How to Choose

Your stucco test found moisture. Here is what targeted repair, full remediation with new stucco, and re-cladding with siding each involve, and what usually decides it.

Estimated Read Time:

Share:

Before and after: home exterior re-sided by Infinity Home Remodeling

Your stucco test came back with high moisture readings. Now what? For most homeowners in Bucks and Montgomery County, the choice comes down to three paths: repair the problem areas, remediate the walls and put new stucco back on over a properly drained wall, or remove the stucco and re-clad the house with siding. Each can be the right call. This article explains what each option involves and the factors that usually decide it, so you can have a better conversation with your contractor.

If you have not had testing done yet, start with our guide to stucco moisture problems in Pennsylvania homes. This article picks up after the report is in.

First, understand what failed

The decision makes more sense once you know why stucco walls get wet. Building Science Corporation classifies stucco as a “reservoir cladding”: like brick, concrete and wood, it absorbs water and stores it. Its guidance is that stucco applied over water-sensitive materials such as wood sheathing must be separated from them, and that drainage requires two things: a drainage plane and a drainage space. Even a small gap can drain water. The firm notes drainage can occur in spaces as small as 1/16 to 1/8 inch, such as between two layers of building paper behind stucco.

The U.S. Department of Energy’s Building America Solution Center puts it plainly: stucco is porous and will always crack, even when installed perfectly. The key is a good drainage plane behind the stucco that drains to a weep system at the bottom of the wall. In other words, the stucco itself is rarely the whole problem. Missing drainage, missing or reverse-lapped flashing, and leaks at windows and roof lines usually are.

That matters because every option below has to fix those details. New stucco installed the old way would repeat the old problem. Siding installed without a proper water-resistive barrier and flashing would not be much better.

Option 1: Targeted repair

When testing shows elevated moisture in a limited area with a clear cause, such as one window or one missing kick-out flashing where a roof meets a wall, a targeted repair may be enough. That generally means opening the wall in the affected area, replacing damaged sheathing or framing, correcting the flashing, rebuilding the water-resistive barrier and patching the stucco.

Things to weigh:

  • Is the cause truly isolated? If similar windows on other sides of the house were flashed the same way, the problem may not be.
  • Tying new work into old. The repaired section has to connect to the existing wall layers, which can be tricky if the original wall had no real drainage plane.
  • Appearance. Ask how the patched area will be finished so it blends with the rest of the wall.

ASTM E2128, the standard guide for evaluating water leakage of building walls, treats a wall as a system that includes its finishes, windows and structure. That is a useful mindset here: a repair should address the cause, not only the wet spot.

Option 2: Full remediation with new stucco

When moisture is widespread, remediation usually means removing the stucco from the affected walls, repairing the structure and installing a new, properly detailed stucco system. A manufacturer case study from a Doylestown neighborhood describes what this can involve on one home: removing about 3,700 square feet of stucco from the sides and back, replacing sheathing, framing and band board, pulling and resetting windows and doors, installing proper flashing and a drainable housewrap, and allowing about six weeks of cure time for the new cladding.

Pennsylvania’s code has also changed. According to Penn State’s Pennsylvania Housing Research Center (PHRC), when the Uniform Construction Code updated to the 2018 ICC codes in early 2022, Pennsylvania adopted stucco and stone provisions based on the 2021 International Residential Code. The PHRC explains that in moist or marine climate zones, those provisions add a space or drainage material not less than 3/16 inch deep on the outside of the water-resistive barrier, in addition to the layered barrier requirements, and that a rainscreen drainage space is now required for exterior stucco and adhered masonry veneer. The new stucco assemblies also reference updated ASTM standards for lath and plaster (ASTM C1063 and C926).

So new stucco today is a different wall than many homes in our area were built with. If you love the look of stucco, a correctly detailed drained system is the way to keep it. Ask any contractor to show you, in writing, the water-resistive barrier, drainage space, flashing and weep details they plan to use.

Option 3: Remove the stucco and re-clad with siding

Many homeowners use remediation as the moment to change the look of the house. Once the stucco is off and the structure is repaired, the wall can be finished with siding, such as fiber cement or vinyl, or a mix of materials. The contractor in the Doylestown case study notes that it replaces stucco with siding, stone or a combination.

Siding still depends on what is behind it. The Polymeric Exterior Products Association, which publishes the vinyl siding installation manual, states that vinyl siding should be installed over a continuous water-resistive barrier to stop incidental water. Building Science Corporation lists fiber cement among claddings that absorb water to some degree, so it also needs the right layers behind it. Flashing at every window, door and roof intersection matters just as much with siding as it does with stucco.

Our stucco removal page explains how we approach this work, and our siding page shows replacement options.

What usually drives the decision

  • How widespread the moisture is. One wet area points toward repair. Elevated readings on several walls usually point toward remediation of those walls or the whole house.
  • The condition of the structure. Once the wall is open, the amount of rotted sheathing and framing often decides the scope.
  • Windows and doors. Many stucco problems start at window openings. If windows have to be pulled and reset, or are near the end of their useful life, it may make sense to plan window work at the same time. See our windows and doors page.
  • The look you want. Some homeowners want to keep the stucco character; others want a different exterior.
  • Neighborhood rules. If you have a homeowners association or live in a historic district, check its rules before changing materials.
  • Selling plans. If you plan to sell, keep your testing reports, remediation documents and permits organized so you can show what was done.
  • Permits. Structural repairs and re-cladding may require permits under your municipality’s administration of the Uniform Construction Code. Check with your township or borough before work starts.

Frequently asked questions

Can I just patch the cracks and seal the stucco?

Patching the surface does not remove water already trapped behind the stucco or fix missing flashing or drainage. Building America notes stucco will always crack, so the wall needs a drainage plane and weep system behind it.

Is new stucco installed differently than it used to be?

Yes. According to Penn State’s PHRC, Pennsylvania’s 2022 code update adopted stucco provisions from the 2021 International Residential Code, including a drainage space behind the stucco in moist climates and updated water-resistive barrier requirements.

Does siding need a water barrier behind it too?

Yes. The vinyl siding industry’s installation guidance says vinyl siding should be installed over a continuous water-resistive barrier, and proper flashing at openings is just as important as with stucco.

How do I know which option is right for my house?

Start with independent moisture testing to understand how widespread the problem is, then compare written proposals that spell out the wall layers, flashing and drainage details for each option.

If you are weighing stucco remediation against new siding, we can walk the house with you, review your test results and put the options in writing. Request a free estimate. For the building science behind it, see Building Science Corporation’s information sheet on reservoir claddings.

Other Posts