Serving Bucks & Montgomery Counties, Southeastern Pennsylvania and nearby New JerseyServing Southeastern PA & nearby NJMon–Fri 8am–8pm · Sat 8am–2pm · Customer Login

Stucco Moisture Problems in Pennsylvania Homes: What to Know

Stucco Moisture Problems in Pennsylvania Homes: What to Know

Stucco itself is rarely the problem; what is behind it is. Here is a calm, fact-checked look at why water gets trapped, how testing works and what your options are.

Estimated Read Time:

Share:

Before and after: home exterior re-sided by Infinity Home Remodeling

If you own a stucco home in southeastern Pennsylvania, you have probably heard about stucco moisture problems from a neighbor, a real estate agent or the local news. Some of that talk is well founded and some of it is not. The goal of this article is to explain, calmly and accurately, what actually goes wrong, how to look for warning signs, how testing works, and what your options are if a problem is found.

Stucco itself is not the villain

The trouble usually comes from what is behind it and how the wall was detailed. As one stucco remediation specialist put it in a 2016 6abc Action News report on the issue in the Philadelphia suburbs, “It’s not the stucco per se that’s the problem. It’s really truly what’s underneath.”

Why water gets trapped

Building Science Corporation, a well-known building-science research firm, classifies stucco as a “reservoir cladding.” Like brick, concrete and other masonry-type finishes, stucco absorbs water and holds it. That stored water can migrate into the wall if the stucco sits directly against moisture-sensitive materials such as wood sheathing and framing.

Their guidance is that stucco applied over water-sensitive materials must be separated from them. That means:

  • A drainage plane, such as building paper or housewrap, that sheds water.
  • A drainage space so water that gets behind the stucco has a path down and out. Even a small gap, such as the space between two layers of building paper, can work.
  • A capillary break, such as an air space, foam sheathing or the drainage layer itself, so water is not wicked inward.

When sun heats wet stucco, it can also drive moisture inward toward the wall cavity, which is one more reason the layers behind it matter.

Where water gets in

Most problems trace back to openings and intersections rather than the flat field of the wall:

  • Windows and doors. In a manufacturer case study of stucco homes in a Doylestown neighborhood, improper sill flashing and reverse-lapped flashing at window openings contributed to serious moisture problems. Window flashing was also a recurring theme in the 6abc reporting.
  • Roof-to-wall intersections. The U.S. Department of Energy’s Building America Solution Center shows an example where missing kick-out flashing, the small diverter at the bottom edge of a roof that meets a wall, led to staining and water damage behind stucco next to a second-story window.
  • The bottom edge of the wall. A weep screed, a metal or plastic strip at the base of the stucco, is meant to let trapped water drain to the outside. If it is missing, buried by soil or mulch, or blocked, water has nowhere to go.
  • Penetrations such as light fixtures, hose bibs, vents and utility lines.

Why this comes up so often in our area

Stucco moisture problems have been reported across the Philadelphia suburbs, including in Bucks, Chester, Delaware and Montgomery counties. The 2016 6abc report described homes in towns such as Doylestown, West Chester and Glen Mills, and noted that the damage is often invisible from the outside. Experts in that report attributed it to construction mistakes combined with Northeast weather.

The common thread is wood-framed homes clad in stucco without the drainage and flashing details described above. The 6abc report noted the issue affected older homes as well as newer construction.

Signs worth paying attention to

Stucco moisture damage is often hidden, so the absence of visible signs does not prove a wall is dry. That said, these are worth noting:

  • Staining or dark streaks below window corners or where a roof meets a wall.
  • Visible cracks in the stucco.
  • Discoloration, bubbling paint, or soft or deteriorating trim near the stucco.
  • Soil, mulch or paving built up against the bottom edge of the stucco.

Benjamin Obdyke, a manufacturer of moisture-management building products, notes that staining and cracks suggest there may be moisture behind the stucco, but that a subsurface problem can only be confirmed through a professional inspection.

How stucco moisture testing works

Invasive (probe) testing

For conventional hard-coat stucco, invasive testing is the standard approach. An inspector makes small penetration holes at targeted locations, typically around windows, doors, roof-to-wall junctions and utility access points, and uses probes to measure the moisture content of the structure behind the stucco. Ask the inspector ahead of time how the holes will be closed up afterward. Home inspection firm U.S. Inspect describes invasive probing as the most accurate way to assess homes with conventional hard-coat stucco.

What about infrared cameras?

Thermal (infrared) imaging is non-invasive and can help point to areas worth investigating. However, U.S. Inspect cautions that its results are often not definitive, and that probing is still needed to verify moisture in the underlying structure.

Deeper investigation

Where leaks are confirmed, investigators may need to open up sections of wall to find the source. ASTM E2128, the Standard Guide for Evaluating Water Leakage of Building Walls, covers methods for determining the causes of wall leaks and acknowledges that some of those techniques may be intrusive, disruptive or destructive.

One practical tip from the 6abc reporting: a building-science consultant recommended using a separate, independent firm for testing rather than the company that would do the repairs. That advice is worth considering no matter who you hire.

Repair or remediation?

Localized repair

When testing shows elevated moisture in only a small, well-defined area, and the cause is clear (for example, a single window or a missing kick-out flashing), a localized repair may be appropriate. That means opening the affected area, replacing any damaged sheathing or framing, correcting the flashing, and rebuilding the wall layers properly. Patching a crack or caulking the surface alone does not address water already trapped behind the stucco.

Full remediation

When moisture is widespread, the usual path is remediation: removing the stucco from the affected walls, replacing damaged sheathing and framing, installing proper flashing at windows and doors, adding a drainable water-resistive barrier, and then re-cladding. In the Doylestown case study, remediation involved removing stucco, replacing sheathing, framing and band board, resetting windows and doors, and installing a drainable housewrap and new flashing before the new cladding went on.

Re-cladding does not have to mean stucco again. Some homeowners choose to replace stucco with siding, such as fiber cement or vinyl, over a properly detailed wall. Our stucco removal page explains how we approach this work, and our siding page shows replacement options.

Frequently asked questions

Does every stucco home in Pennsylvania have a moisture problem?

No. Problems depend on how the wall was built and detailed, especially drainage behind the stucco and flashing at windows, doors and roof lines. Testing is the way to know for a specific house.

Can an infrared camera tell me if my stucco is wet?

It can help point to areas worth checking, but its results are often not definitive. For conventional hard-coat stucco, invasive probe testing is considered the more reliable method.

What happens during an invasive stucco test?

An inspector makes small holes at targeted spots, usually around windows, doors and roof-to-wall junctions, and uses probes to measure moisture in the structure behind the stucco. Ask ahead of time how the holes will be closed up.

If moisture is found, do I have to remove all the stucco?

Not always. A small, well-defined problem with a clear cause may be repaired locally. Widespread moisture usually calls for removing the stucco on affected walls, repairing the structure, and re-cladding over a properly drained wall.

If you already have test results, or you are weighing stucco removal and new siding, we are glad to walk the house with you and talk through options. Request a free estimate. For a deeper technical read, see Building Science Corporation’s information sheet on reservoir claddings.

Other Posts